10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Property Manager in Geelong
Comparing management fees is a natural part of investing. On the surface, a lower fee looks like an easy win: lower costs, same result. But in property management, what you don't see matters most.
When your investment feels easy (rent paid on time, few issues, steady renters), that isn't luck. It's the result of systems, experience and proactive management working in the background. These questions help you find out whether that's what you're paying for.
Why a low fee can cost more
Discounted fees often come with trade-offs: junior or inexperienced managers, too many properties per manager, missed inspections and rent reviews, slow maintenance and poor lease renewal planning. Each one increases your exposure to lost income, preventable vacancies and higher maintenance costs.
In many cases, the difference between a low-fee agency and a proactive manager is less than $8 a week. One missed rent review, one delayed repair or one extended vacancy can cost far more than that.
The questions to ask
- What experience does my property manager have? Look for clear years of experience, stability within the agency and knowledge of your local market. Be wary of answers that avoid naming who will actually manage your property.
- How many properties does each manager look after? High numbers slow response times and reduce attention to detail. A strong agency caps each manager's portfolio and can explain why.
- What percentage of your renters pay on time? Ask for arrears figures and how they follow up. "Arrears are normal" is a red flag.
- How do you stay ahead of law changes? Victorian rental laws change regularly. Look for ongoing training and proactive updates to owners, not "we'll deal with it if it comes up".
- How many properties are on fixed-term leases? Lapsed leases reduce control and make planning harder.
- What percentage of repair requests are open beyond 14 days? Slow repairs increase costs, damage renter relationships and create compliance risk.
- How often are routine inspections done? Look for fixed inspection cycles and low overdue rates. Ask to see an example inspection report.
- How many disputes and tribunal cases have you handled recently? Frequent VCAT visits often point to weak screening or communication.
- What are your average days on market? Vacancy is one of the biggest costs investors face, so ask for real data for your suburb.
- How will you grow my rental return over time? Look for regular, data-backed rent reviews, low-cost improvement ideas and a plan to minimise vacancy.
Use them on your current manager too
You don't need to be changing agents to ask these questions. If your current manager can't answer them clearly, it's worth knowing now rather than after a long vacancy or a missed rent review.
Want to talk it through? Book a complimentary consult with Sophie to discuss your experience, expectations, your current setup and the best approach for your property.